19 Fantastic Supernatural Movies You Probably Haven’t Seen

Source Code, hands down the best movie on parallel realities I have seen.

I LOVE a good supernatural/metaphysically themed movie and collect them in my mind. Tons of gore is a real turn off, but great story lines attract me like a vampire to virgins. So here is my list of some fantastic little gems you may have missed.

1) What We Do in the Shadows

What we do in the shadows movie review

(2014) So happy to see a really good, new vampire movie. I love to watch this one and just crack up laughing. All the usual vampire themes done in a refreshing new way, modern day bachelor style. If you like vampires, you gotta see this outstanding little independent film.


2) Devil’s Backbone

Devil's Backbone review

(2001) This is one of Guillermo del Toro’s best, and little known (in America) films. If you are the type of person I think you are (because you are reading this list!) then you will love this enchanted yet serious film set in Spain during Spanish Civil War. Performances are fantastic, story is incredibly rich, tragic, and HAUNTED.


3) Man Facing Southeast

Man facing southeast review

(1986) A wonderful Argentinean film about a guy from another world with supernatural abilities who winds up in the looney bin (of course.) A provocative, moving little piece of art that will stay with you for a long time to come.


4) Mothman Prophecies

Mothman Prophecies Alan Bates Richard Gere

(2002) Watching this in the theatre back in the day left me permanently SPOOKED. Based on a true story, the cinematography is incredible (watch on as large a screen as possible,) and the story is downright creepy. This film impacted me so much I read the entire book of same title (on which movie is based,) with dry but interesting true investigation of this event. Richard Gere, Laura Linney, Will Patton, Debra Messing and Alan Bates.


5) The Haunting

The Haunting Review

(1963) Black and white weirdness in this psycho thriller from times gone by. Julie Harris is sublime and wonderful to watch in this twisted, quirky tale.


6) 1408

Room 1408 Review

This one will have your heart pounding harder than most if not all on this list. But not your typical thriller, by any stretch. The story is clever and sophisticated supernatural juice. Don’t watch this by yourself.


7) Powder

Powder movie review

(1995) A weird, brave flick you just can’t leave off a list like this. If you’ve ever felt like an outsider, you will relate to Powder.


8) The Lost Room

Lost Room review margaret cho

Actually a mini series, I have yet to mention it to anyone who has ever heard of it before. SUCH A GREAT RIDE. Starring Peter Krause (from Six Feet Under) and Julianna Margulies, this is an amazing maze of supernatural fun, unexpected characters, great acting, and profound and unusual insight on the nature of dreams and reality. Several hours of addicting drama.


9) Source Code

Source Code review

(2011) Jake Gyllenhaal, Vera Farmiga, Michelle Monaghan. Another incredible piece of cinema it seems no one has heard of. Hands down best movie I have seen on the nature of parallel realities. Do not miss this one.


 10) Beauty and the Beast

Beauty and the Beast review

(1946) Directed by Jean Cocteau. Fairytale and visual poetry combine in this work of cinematic art. A beautiful, enchanted film.


11) Don’t Look Now

Don't Look Now review

(1973) Donald Sutherland is really good in this aging flick involving premonition, dealing with the loss of a loved one, and just plain weirdness. Eye candy as Julie Christie and scenes of Venice, Italy fill the screen, and of course Donald is so damn out there he’s always a pleasure even if the writing is, well, so so.


12) Shadow of the Vampire

Shadow of the Vampire, Willem DaFoe

(2000) Pulling from Nosferatu for vampire ideas instead of the typical “Dracula” themes, I found this movie refreshing in the genre. Plus, any excuse to check out John Malkovich and Willem Dafoe in the same movie is too much of a draw to pass up. Dafoe’s performance as vampire, “Max Schrek,” is not to be missed.


13) Drag Me to Hell

Drag Me to Hell Alison Lohman

(2009) There is no way I would have ever seen a movie with a title such as this unless I was literally “dragged” to it, which is exactly what happened. So happy I was :-))) I can watch this thing over and over, and I do – cracking up every time. It is so hilarious, so campy, so well done and so well written, I might just have to be buried with this DVD in my cold stiff hands. Written and directed by Sam Raimi (of Spiderman notoriety,) and starring Alison Lohman.


14) Pan’s Labyrinth

Pan's Labyrinth review

(2006) To me, this film is consummate joy on any terms. It is so well done, start to finish, the magic has you by the throat as you enter this world through the person of a young girl. It is not a child’s movie, though, but a fantastic adult fairytale. After you watch this, watch it again with Guillermo del Toro narrating, where you will find the story secrets and brilliant artistic nuances you missed the first time.


15) House on Haunted Hill

house on haunted hill 1959 review

(1959) Don’t bother with the (awful) remake of this classic. Go for the original and enjoy a classic Vincent Price performance. Campy, dated, and all that good stuff.


16) Mars Attacks

Mars Attacks review

(1996) Who could live a truly full and complete existence without the memory of this ridiculous sci-fi living inside their brain? Scenes of Sarah Jessica Parker’s head attached to the body of a chihuahua pop up into my brain in the weirdest, most random moments, and will keep me chuckling forever. An early Tim Burton film, starring Jack Nicholson, Glenn Close, Pierce Brosnan, Danny DeVito, a young Natalie Portman, Martin Short, Jack Black.


17) The Nines

The Nines movie review

(2007) Ryan Reynolds, Melissa McCarthy, Hope Davis and Elle Fanning bring a provocative new twist to our supernatural movie genre, with Ryan Reynolds being haunted by himself as he exists in parallel lifetimes. This one will keep you on your toes, and have you arguing with your spouse about what actually happens at the end.


18) Resurrection

Resurrection 1980 movie review ellen burstyn

(1980) A young Ellen Burstyn stars in this old classic supernatural movie. After experiencing an NDE, miraculous healing abilities emerge, and the urge to help conflicts with not wanting to draw fanatical, small town attention to herself. Sam Shepard also stars.


19) The Gift

The Gift 2000 Review

(2000) A MUST SEE for all you card readers out there. Great card reading scenes, plus chock full of psychic day dreams, psychic night dreams, ghosts, superstion and muuurrrrrddddeeeerrrrr……. EW! Just gave myself the chills! AMAZING cast of Cate Blanchett, Katie Holmes, Giovanni Ribisi, Hilary Swank, Keanu Reeves, Greg Kinnear, and more :-))


  • Thanx for sharing list.. some are seen already. But most of are new. We watch ya 🙂

  • Carina says:

    I’ve only seen the German dub of “What We Do in the Shadows”: “4 Zimmer, Küche, Sarg” (4 rooms, kitchen, coffin – like a description of a home in an ad). It was so hilarious. Also because of funny accents. I’ll have to check out the English dub someday.

  • Darryl says:

    Sounds like I need to rent some more movies. Thank you for posting this! 🙂

  • kerry says:

    I saw 7 of them,enjoyed Powder,and Beauty and the Beast,which has English subtitiles,but is very powerful,I still think about this movie even after seeing it 20 yrs ago..

  • Charlie says:

    There’s a good reason for not seeing Room 1408. Terrible movie.

  • Rod says:

    A great list with some typical and common titles, but then you went and surprised me with “Resurrection”, a terrific older (and relatively obscure) film from the ’80s that wish they’d release on DVD or Blu ray.

  • Joe Ricca says:

    Room 1408 is actually just “1408” and it is without a doubt one of the best on this list. This is the one I recommend to folks that do not like blood. I have yet to receive a complaint.

    p.s. it’s another Stephen King masterpiece.

    • ana says:

      Joe, thanks for the correction! I agree. great flick. i forgot, a Stephen King piece. Makes it all the more cool :=)

      • John Gartland says:

        Not really a correction as such because it was released in Britain and Ireland as “Room 1408”.
        Now, please check out “Whistle and I’ll come to you”, an M.R. James story made by the BBC in 1968 and remade again in the 2000s. The original is in black and white and is terrifying. Your hairs will stand on end.
        Best Regards,

  • Santi says:

    I’ve seen all of them except for The lost room (but I’ll put a remedy to that as soon as it finishes downloading) Powder and Mars attacks suck balls big time but the rest of them are pretty good

  • Avianti says:

    I love the movie “Beauty and the beast”. I’m not enjoying horror movies. More I like comedies and drama. But anyway thanks for sharing.

    • ana says:

      Thanks Avianti. I would consider the minority of these horror movies. Make sure to look past the titles. Sometimes titles are deceiving.

  • Razor Mouse says:

    Realy nice list to watch.

  • sneha lodha says:

    Beauty and Beast is the best movie. However, I will love to see the mentioned horror movies in this list.

  • Beautiful list, i had seen Drag me to hell. It was really dangerous. Will follow ur list. Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *